Traveling with a group of educators on this trip has been really interesting. One of the highlights of our time in Korea was visiting a school. In the days after that visit we have had a number of interesting discussions about the education system in Korea and in the United States. If I had children I would not send them to a Korean school as it is driven by tests and focuses on reiterating facts rather than exploring options. There is a wave of Korean families that are moving to the USA for education and splitting the time between the two countries.
I always get aggravated when I read news articles about how far behind the United States is compared to other nations. Yes, we are dumb linguistically, but we are also amongst the brightest in science and entrepreneurship. Again, the ranking and stats vary depending on what lens you view them through. There are numerous studies done from a variety of angles with regards to collective intelligence. We are also the only nation in the world that educated everyone through high school In every other nation, students must pass tests to be able to go to middle school and high school. Those articles I mentioned compare all US high school students to a small elite in other nations. It's not a fair or accurate comparison.
Here's a run down of the positives and negatives for Korean and American educational systems:
Korea:
-high value placed on education and educators
-advancement through education and status through education
-based on test taking/extremely high stakes testing
-lack of creativity and individual thought or analysis
-K-12 course work is challenging, Korean educational system does not constantly "dumb down"
-focus on international languages and strong view of Korea as part of the international stage
-core classes are intense and rigorous
-very little special education
-has numerous paths of high school education
United States:
-we have special education and differentiated instruction
-we attempt to foster creativity, individual thought, and analysis
-low math, reading, and writing scores, although we are some of the best internationally in economics and science
-little societal value placed on education and educators
-lack of foreign languages in the classroom
-greater freedom in education
-we educate everyone to 12th grade
These are just some of the topics we debated over the last few days. There are pros and cons to each side of the debate and one can not discuss education without looking at the larger cultural and societal issues at hand.
Perspective keeps coming back as the main theme for me. The whole point of this trip has been to open our eyes to new ways of thinking about issues, viewing topics from different perspectives, and gaining greater appreciation for others.
Tuesday, July 7, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Very interesting perspective - I suspect you will be debating these topics for many years to come! Not only is your blog interesting to read; it's very thought provoking - thank you! Safe travels to Japan...we love you!
ReplyDelete